But would you allow Kruke & Kuip in your amateur baseball league?
An interesting question; they're far enough removed from their professional careers that I'm not sure it would be such a big deal. I'd love having either of them as a coach, at least.
But in any event, the analogy to Best Fan Writer doesn't work because
fan <> amateur
"Amateur" and "Pro" are opposites, but "Fan" and "Pro" are not.
Some people may read "Best Fan Writer" to mean "Best Amateur Writer" or "Best Non-Professional Writer;" however, that is not the intent of the category, and never has been.
no subject
But in any event, the analogy to Best Fan Writer doesn't work because
fan <> amateur
"Amateur" and "Pro" are opposites, but "Fan" and "Pro" are not.
Some people may read "Best Fan Writer" to mean "Best Amateur Writer" or "Best Non-Professional Writer;" however, that is not the intent of the category, and never has been.